AI Grading for Teachers: 100 Free Essays, Both Caps at 350
Every AI grader advertises a free plan, and none of them says on the front page that the free plan covers one assignment for one class set.
📜 Table of Contents
Two of the four tools teachers actually compare give away a real free tier, and the numbers are 100 essays a month (EssayGrader) and 150 submissions a month (CoGrader). Both paid tiers land on 350. The fourth, Gradescope, is free but its free plan does not include AI grading at all, which the pricing page states only in a comparison table.
Prices and quotas below were read from each vendor's pricing page on 21 November 2026. No trial was run, and no accuracy claim from any vendor is repeated here as fact.
The four plans, side by side
| tool | free plan | free cap, per month | per-essay limit | first paid tier | paid cap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EssayGrader | Basic, $0 | 100 essays | 1,000 words | $14.99, Pro | 350 essays |
| CoGrader | Starter, $0 | 150 submissions | not stated | $15 annual / $19 monthly | 350 submissions |
| Gradescope | Basic, $0 | not a submission cap | n/a | Institutional, quote | AI grading is paid-only |
| MagicSchool | Free, $0 forever | no submission counter | n/a | $8.33 per user, annual | same counter |
That table is the whole buying decision for most people, and none of the four pricing pages puts it in one place.
Free means a quota, and the quota is one assignment
A teacher with five classes of 30 has 150 students. One essay per student is 150 submissions. CoGrader's free tier covers exactly that one assignment and then stops. EssayGrader's covers two thirds of it: 100 essays means three of those five classes get graded, and the other two get nothing until the month resets.
Both free tiers are sized for "try it on a real class", not for "run my grading on it". That is a fair design, but it means the free plan cannot be the plan you build a semester around, and the vendor pages do not say so with numbers.
The second limit: 1,000 words per essay
EssayGrader's Basic plan caps each essay at 1,000 words. In classroom terms that is roughly two double-spaced pages, which covers a short response or a one-paragraph analysis and rules out lab reports, research papers and most AP long-form work. The paid Premium tier raises the cap to 8,000 words; the Pro tier's page text states the 350-essay count and does not state a word cap at all, so if your assignments run long, that is a question for support before you buy, not after.
CoGrader's pricing page lists no per-essay word cap on either tier. Absence of a stated cap is not a guarantee of no cap; it means the page does not publish one, and the honest reading is "ask".
Gradescope's free plan does not include AI grading
Gradescope is free on the Basic plan, and it is genuinely useful for what it does: dynamic rubrics, PDF submissions, regrade requests, statistics, data export. The feature comparison on its pricing page lists AI-Powered Grading and AI-Powered Roster Matching as Institutional features, marked absent from Basic. So a teacher searching for a free AI grader and landing on Gradescope gets a free grading workflow without the AI part.
That is not a knock. It is the detail that decides whether Gradescope belongs in your comparison at all. If the requirement is "AI grades the essays", the free plan fails the requirement on the first line.
Cost per submission once you pay
Divide price by cap and the two $350 plans converge, which is the useful part of this comparison:
| plan | price | cap | cost per essay |
|---|---|---|---|
| EssayGrader Pro | $14.99/month | 350 | 4.3 cents |
| CoGrader Individual, annual | $15/month | 350 | 4.3 cents |
| CoGrader Individual, monthly | $19/month | 350 | 5.4 cents |
| EssayGrader Premium | $34.99/month | 800 | 4.4 cents |
Four to five cents a submission is the going rate between 350 and 800. The spread that matters is not the price, it is the cap: 800 essays against 350 is 2.3 times the capacity for 2.3 times the money, so the per-essay price barely moves. Premium is the only tier here that states an 8,000-word limit, which is what higher-ed and research writing needs.
Compare that with a general teacher tool. MagicSchool is $0 forever, or $8.33 per user per month billed annually ($12.99 monthly), and its pricing page does not meter grading by submission count. What it does not publish is a per-essay, rubric-mapped grade for a whole class in one pass, which is the specific job the two graders above are selling.
What to calculate before you pay
One multiplication decides the tier: classes x students per class x essays per month. For the 150-student teacher that is 300 submissions at two essays a month, which fits CoGrader at $15 or EssayGrader at $14.99 with 50 left over, and does not fit either free plan after the first assignment.
Then check the two caps that multiplication hides: words per essay against the plan's stated limit, and whether the free tier's integrations include the LMS your school actually uses. CoGrader's free Starter plan lists Google Classroom, Canvas and Schoology, which covers the common cases; EssayGrader's Basic lists LMS integrations without naming one on the pricing page, so verify yours inside a trial before committing a semester to it.
What none of these pages tell you
None of them publishes a per-essay error rate, and the accuracy claims that do appear are vendor-run. CoGrader's research page states its grader landed within one point of Texas STAAR raters in 98.3% of cases, measured by CoGrader; EssayGrader states it is used by 200,000+ teachers. Both may be true. Neither is a controlled comparison against a human grader on your rubric, on your students' writing, which is the only number that decides whether the tool saves you time or creates regrade work.
The test that costs nothing: run ten essays you have already graded by hand through the free tier, compare the scores criterion by criterion, and count how many you would have to change. Ten essays fits inside every free quota on this page.
Building the rubric first makes that test meaningful; what the rubric tools charge is in AI rubric generator prices. If the workflow includes generating the quiz as well as grading it, the answer-key checks are in the test maker answer key workflow. The wider free-tool list, including lesson planning, is in AI for teachers, free and lesson plan generators compared.
Pricing is one way a teacher hits a wall. Item quality is the other: a numeric table turned into 60 lookup items with no calculation in them, and 18 of 60 unit mix-ups once a calculation was demanded: the table run.
Written by our editorial team; tools listed here are tested or verified against public sources. Links point to official sites or GitHub repos for reference only — no paid placements.